Black mass payables, explained
Updated
A black mass payable is the percentage of the contained metal's value that a buyer pays for the black mass. If a lot holds $5,000 of nickel and cobalt at reference prices and the payable is 80%, the seller receives $4,000 a tonne. Payables are how most nickel and cobalt black mass (NMC, NCA and LCO) is priced.
How a payable is calculated
For each payable metal: grade × reference price × payable %, summed over the metals. The reference price is set in the contract, usually the LME nickel price and a standard cobalt metal price outside China, and the prices of nickel sulfate, cobalt sulfate and lithium carbonate inside China.
A worked example, using end-of-life NMC811 black mass and the calculator's reference prices on October 3, 2026 (nickel $15,536/t, cobalt $33,000/t, the cobalt figure a manual estimate):
| Grade | Contained value per tonne | |
|---|---|---|
| Nickel | 26.5% | $4,125 |
| Cobalt | 3.3% | $1,100 |
| Total | $5,225 |
At an 82% payable, the European average for August 2026, the buyer pays $4,284 a tonne. At 106.5%, the last published US level, it pays $5,564. The lithium in the lot, about 3.9%, is not paid for separately in either case.
Payables by region
These are the region presets the calculator uses. Each is a dated figure from a price agency report; click the date for the source.
| Region | Nickel | Cobalt | Lithium | Share of | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Europe EXW Europe | 82% | 82% | not paid | Nickel: LME nickel cash; Cobalt: standard-grade cobalt metal | 2026-08 |
| South Korea / Asia CIF South Korea | 103% | 103% | 3.25% | Nickel: LME nickel cash; Cobalt: standard-grade cobalt metal; Lithium: Li₂CO₃ CIF CJK | 2026-08 |
| China EXW China | 76.3% | 76.3% | 76.3% | Nickel: nickel sulfate; Cobalt: cobalt sulfate; Lithium: lithium carbonate | 2026-09-01 |
| United States EXW USA | 106.5% | 106.5% | not paid | Nickel: LME nickel cash; Cobalt: standard-grade cobalt metal | 2026-06-10 |
China's payables are a percentage of salt prices (nickel sulfate, cobalt sulfate, lithium carbonate), not metal prices, so the percentages are not directly comparable with the other regions. In the calculator, enter the salt price per tonne of contained metal as the payable basis price to use them correctly.
Why payables can be above 100%
A payable over 100% means the buyer pays more than the reference value of the nickel and cobalt. That makes sense to a buyer when:
- The reference price is lower than what the refiner earns. Refiners sell nickel and cobalt as sulfates, which can trade above the metal price, and in markets that do not pay for lithium separately, the lithium's value is built into the nickel and cobalt payable.
- Feed is scarce. Refining capacity has been built faster than batteries are retiring, so refiners bid up the black mass that exists. Benchmark had Asian NCM payables (CIF) at 107.5% at the end of the third quarter of 2026, even after a 10.4% fall that quarter (Benchmark, Q3 2026).
- Rules restrict where black mass can go. Since August 27, 2026, US recyclers must sell all their black mass to US buyers unless granted an exception. Fastmarkets suspended its US payables assessment on September 1, 2026, and Benchmark's North American payables fell 13.6% over the quarter.
What payable can a recycler afford?
The calculator answers this as the implied payable and the margin. For a hydrometallurgical refinery with Argonne EverBatt's US costs, 10,000 tonnes a year of end-of-life NMC811 black mass and October 3, 2026 prices, the margin is zero at a nickel and cobalt payable of about:
- 68% if the lithium is sold as crude lithium carbonate at half the battery-grade price (EverBatt's assumption), or
- 97% if it is sold at the full battery-grade price.
Both are below the 103–107% paid in South Korea and the US over the summer of 2026. On these assumptions, a Western refinery paying those payables loses money on every tonne, which is consistent with the losses and restructurings across the sector. More on what the numbers say.
Compare the regions yourself: NMC811 at European payables, South Korean payables or US payables.